I was very impressed with Penn State’s performance in Madison this past Saturday night; it was the kind of victory that is solidifying PSU as one of the best all-around teams in the country. Daryll Clark has been the most impressive player during this team’s rise to 2008 football glory. Against Wisconsin, Clark proved himself as a passer more than he has all season. Quite simply, Clark is playing lights-out football.
However, Daryll Clark is being outshined by the holier-than-thou Big 12 quarterback club. I watched the Red River Shootout and was extremely impressed with both Colt McCoy and Sam Bradford…honestly, who wouldn’t be? Bradford has thrown for 23 TD’s already this season and McCoy has completed 79.4% of his throws. These huge stats continue through the rest of the conference with quarterbacks like Chase Daniel, Graham Harrell, and Todd Reesing. How did this conference give birth to so many aerial assaults?
There are many possible answers to that question, but I think maybe poor defense has something to do with it. Don’t get me wrong – when you have a gifted offense like many Big 12 teams do, you’re going to score some points. But you would figure that inter-conference rivalries would slow high-scoring teams. Oklahoma State did a good job of forcing turnovers on Saturday night, intercepting Chase Daniel three times, the first time he’s been picked since the season debut against Illinois (showcasing his, well, God-like abilities during that time). But Daniel still threw for 390 yards in a close game.
Oklahoma, who Kirk Herbstreit says is one of the “nastiest defenses in the country”, got gashed for 161 yards on the ground and 277 yards through the air in their close loss to Texas. Vice versa, Sam Bradford lit up the “best defense he has seen by far this year” for 387 yards and 5 TDs (though he did throw two picks). These teams have great playmakers, but defense does not seem to be this conference’s strength.
In fact, Kansas, ranked 27th in the nation in scoring defense, has statistically the best defense in the conference, followed next by Oklahoma at 37. Penn State, on the other hand, is 6th in scoring defense and 8th in total offense allowed. I realize that Penn State racked up those stats against some pretty poor offenses, but the same goes with Kansas, Oklahoma, and the majority of the other Big 12 teams, with their early season, cream-puff schedules. The point is simple: if you’re playing poor teams and you have a good defense, you should be able to win these games without surrendering many points or yards. These Big 12 teams obviously don’t have those kinds of defenses.
And another thing – I keep hearing that the Big 12 is the best offensive conference in DI-A. While this appears to be valid, many supporters of this theory have (obviously) never checked out the eye-popping stats put up by players in the non-BCS, Conference USA. Just check last year’s numbers for guys like Tulsa’s Paul Smith (QB, 5065 passing yards, 60 Total TDs) or Central Florida’s Kevin Smith (RB, 2567 rushing yards, 30 Total TDs), or Tulane’s Matt Forte (RB, 2127 rushing yards, 23 Total TDs), or Eastern Carolina’s Chris Johnson (RB, 1423 rushing yards, 23 Total TDs). All three of those running backs are now in the NFL and are already, or will soon make a difference for their respective teams. This is, overwhelmingly, the best offensive conference in D-IA college football and possibly the worst defensively.
I am still impressed with the big-play Big 12 offenses, but I think Penn State deserves some serious national respect. (Editor’s note: Um, gotta say, I feel as though a national ranking of three is respect). Penn State’s offense is extremely efficient and very balanced, which in turn leads to smaller numbers for Daryll Clark. This may lead to a conclusion that Clark isn’t good enough for consideration in the kissing-the-Big-12-quarterback’s-ass club. (Editor’s note: From what I’ve heard, people leave these club meetings with a bad taste in their mouth). On Saturday night, however, he proved to me that he has the ability to throw with the best of them. He is smart, makes good decisions, and can make every throw across the entire field, regardless if he is standing upright or running for his life. His ability to make plays in the passing game, especially after things have broken down, is amazing. His comparison to Michael Robinson is unfair, because Clark is a true passer who just happens to be able to run (and with some strength). Dare I say he reminds me of a young Donovan McNabb at Syracuse?
Clark is enjoying extreme success in a spread offense that has weapons everywhere (7th in Scoring Offense with 45.3 pts./game), and a team that really doesn’t have any glaring weaknesses (9th in Total Offense, 8th in Total Defense, excellent special teams). Stewart Mandel of Sports Illustrated (probably SI’s best known college football writer) stated, quite frankly, that he hasn’t seen an offense as dynamic and dangerous as Penn State’s since that of the 2004 Utah Utes, led by coach Urban Meyer, who broke into the BCS that year with an undefeated season. Anybody else think Urban Meyer knows how to run a really good spread? Now what about Penn State?
Penn State’s offense is ranked statistically with the best in the nation, but I still don’t think that many analysts realize the stats they’ve compiled. In the first quarter of this Saturday’s Red River Shootout, a stat flashed onto the screen: Oklahoma has outscored their opponents 103-3 in the first quarter this season. Kirk Herbstreit promptly stated, “I don’t know if we’ve seen a stat like that in college football”. Oklahoma improved upon that stat, making it 110-6 by the end of the first quarter in that game, a very impressive stat with a 104 point difference.
Now look at Penn State. Coming into Madison, Penn State had outscored its opponents 110-20 in the second quarter, then improved that stat to 131-27 by halftime; a very impressive stat with the same 104 point difference as Oklahoma in the first quarter. So in a word, Kirk Herbstreit is wrong. I won’t give him that much flack, as Herbstreit seems to be a Penn State supporter himself. In the end though, he played quarterback at Ohio State, which forever leaves a part of him in the realms of douche-bagginess. (Editor’s note: Dot that eye, bitch!).
Coming into this Saturday, I thought Oklahoma had the best all around team in the country. But after seeing them lose and seeing Penn State’s complete dominance, I think the Nittany Lions need to be considered as the nation’s most solid team from top to bottom. I still have much respect for Oklahoma, Texas, Alabama, USC, Florida and the likes (and I realize that Penn State has a ways to go), but PSU is a force to be reckoned with.